Good and Bad Golf Announcers, Analysts and Commentators

From the bland and downright annoying to informative and fun, golf’s on air personalities entertain and sometimes irritate viewers. Here’s a review of the best and worst of golf’s more notable announcers, analysts and commentators:

(Listed alphabetically)

Shane Bacon (Golf Channel)

Co-host of Golf Today, Bacon, who also does play-by-play tournament coverage, is arguably the best young announcer in the business. A former mini-tour player, Bacon knows the game and he has an easy going, entertaining style. Best of all, he doesn’t take himself too seriously as you can see with his podcast (Get a Grip) and his social media posts. It’s a bold prediction on my part, but I believe he could be the next Jim Nantz.

Cara Banks (Golf Channel/Sky Sports)

Smart, knowledgeable and always well informed, Banks is at the top of her game. She’s a superb interviewer who always asks the pertinent questions without being annoying to the interviewee. Consequently, she makes it easy and comfortable to watch. My gosh, with her wonderful, rhythmic English accent, she could read a grocery list and make it sound scholarly and entertaining.

Amanda Balionis (CBS)

She has the perky gene ala Katie Couric, but her post round interviews are predictable and snooze inducing. First question: How does it feel to win or lose? Second question: What went right and what went wrong out there? I don’t know the third question because I’m typically on my way to the fridge for another brewski. If you play a drinking game and take a chug of beer everytime Balionis says the word “unbelievable”, you’ll be totally wasted in short order. Cheers!

Charles Barkley (TNT)

Barkley’s constant ribbing of big name pros and celebrities and his quick wit with hilarious, unfiltered takes make him a joy to watch on “The Match” telecasts on TNT. It doesn’t matter if it’s Tiger Woods, Tom Brady or Justin Thomas, Barkley lets the barbs fly and it’s must see T.V. Regardless of what golf icons are on the telecast, it’s Barkley who always steals the show. The “Chuckster”, a golf fanatic , never holds back on this jokes and opinions and, man, is it fun to watch and listen.

Notah Begay (Golf Channel)

He’s a buddy of Tiger’s going back to their days at Stanford, so Begay is, not surprisingly, a Woods apologist. That said, he offers up some interesting takes on playing between the ropes. Begay’s PGA Tour career was disappointing, but with some seasoning and enough T.V. reps he could turn out to be better analyst. Just, please, don’t ask this guy any Tiger questions because he’ll never bum kick his friend.

Curt Byrum (Golf Channel)

A former PGA Tour and Nike Tour player, Byrum is insightful, easy-to-listen-to and vastly underrated. Not sure most golf fans could pick him out of a line-up. He’s the ultimate professional and because he never says anything controversial or dumb, he hasn’t achieved the notoriety of some other Golf Channel analysts. He had one PGA Tour win, the Hardee’s Golf Classic in 1989, and his highest finish in a major was a T14 in the 1987 PGA Championship.

Andrew Catalon (CBS)

Once the voice of Olympic curling at NBC, the 42-year old Catalon, who subs in for Jim Nantz on PGA TOUR coverage, is considered a rising star at CBS. And for good reason. He doesn’t have the status of Nantz yet — certainly when it comes to golf — but Catalon is always well prepared and offers subtle witty commentary that makes him an easy listen. He does an excellent job of staying in his lane and letting the analyst do his job.

Brandel Chamblee (Golf Channel)

He comes off as somewhat of a know-it-all frat boy with his dapper outfits and Prince Valiant haircut, but Chamblee knows golf. He can break down a swing as well as anyone on T.V. and he’s not afraid to criticize golf’s biggest stars. From Tiger to Phil and many more, Chamblee gets in verbal scrums and never backs down. Some people like his in-your-face-attitude and others despise it. Either way, like the Dallas Cowboys, New York Yankees and Notre Dame Golden Domers, you either love ’em or hate ’em – there doesn’t seem to be a neutral zone with Chamblee.

Luke Donald (NBC)

The 2023 European Ryder Cup Captain and former World No. 1 has been nothing short of phenomenal as a analyst for this year’s Open Championship 2024. While a neophyte in the booth, Donald sounds like he’s been there for years. He’s not flashy, but smooth, measured and concise with his analysis. If you want to learn about links golf, Donald’s description of the experience is spot on.

David Duval (ESPN)

Extremely knowledgable about what it takes to compete on the highest levels of the PGA Tour, Duval is superb at breaking down what it takes to deliver consistently in the big moments, especially majors. Unfortunately, his voice has very little inflection and excitement and I find myself rapidly traveling to sleepyville when he drones on too much.

Ian Baker-Finch (CBS)

“Finchy” as he’s often called on broadcasts, has one of the greatest accents ever.The Aussie, who also does golf for TNT, is knowledgeable and can certainly turn a phrase. Just like Henry Longhurst and Peter Aliss, I can’t get enough of Finchy’s accent.

Nick Faldo (Formerly with CBS)

I like to listen to Sir Nick, but I’m fully aware there are lots of viewers who simply can’t stand the sometimes smug and arrogant British attitude. It’s hard to believe Faldo was so mum with the media when he played. Sir Nick can talk endlessly about golf, which obviously annoys some viewers. He seemingly has an opinion on just about every aspect of the professional game. Banking on memories from his six Major wins, Faldo’s strength is telling the viewer exactly what’s it’s like to play between the ropes, especially during crucial moments. Nobody gets inside the minds of superstar players like Faldo. For those who can’t stand Sir Nick, I guess you got your wish with his recent retirement from CBS.

Brad Faxon (NBC)

Gary Koch and Roger Maltbie got the unceremonious boot from NBC and Faxon, along with Smylie Kaufman, was recruited to “re-energize the broadcast” as the suits at the network like to say. Faxon is articulate and opinionated at times and I see him as a sort of Johnny Miller lite as time goes by. Renowned as one the game’s great putters during his career, the least he can do is offer all of us some quick lessons and insight with the flatstick.

David Feherty (LIV Golf Tour)

He’s just not that funny and he recently brought his tired act to LIV Golf. Feherty always seems more interested in desperately trying to come up with zany one-liners than actually analyzing the golf action around him. It’s sad, most of his jokes crash and burn. I cringe every time the announcer says, “Let’s go to Feherty.” I realize more than a few people think Feherty is humorous, but I would absolutely hate to be sitting on a long flight with him and have to listen to his boorish act.

Jerry Foltz (LIV Golf Tour)

Looks like Jerry took the big payday from Greg Norman and the Saudis and said, “Hasta la vista, baby.” Sadly, he’s quickly become the ultimate annoying homer for the LIV Golf Tour. A knowledgeable commentator and on-course reporter with an underrated wit and an easy going demeanor, Foltz always seems prepared. The biggest question most people have is : “Who the heck is Jerry Foltz?” He played golf at the University of Arizona and won the Arizona Amateur in 1989. He played on the Nike Tour (now the Korn Ferry) and won one tournament, the Nike South Carolina Classic in 1995. In 1990, three days after he turned pro he sustained a serious back injury in an auto accident.

Terry Gannon (Golf Channel)

A smooth talker who typically works on LPGA telecasts, Gannon is one of the best set-up men in the business. No matter who he’s working with, Gannon asks pertinent questions to the analyst and moves the coverage along effortlessly.

Damon Hack (Golf Channel)

Nobody seems to love the game more than Hack, who has been with the Golf Channel since 2012. The co-host of Golf Today with Shane Bacon, Hack’s enthusiasm is infectious when you listen to him and his golf knowledge is impressive. He’s got one of those affable personalities that’s not contrived and his authenticity comes through.

Dan Hicks (NBC)

He’s a solid announcer that never seems to say anything too offensive or annoying. Hicks does a great job of setting up Paul Azinger and making the broadcast flow effortlessly.

Trevor Immelman (CBS)

I’m not sure why, but commentators and analysts with great accents just seem to come off a lot smarter than their American counterparts. Immelman, with his rhythmic South African accent, is easy to listen to and he knows the game at its highest level. You’ll be seeing lots more of him in the near future at he takes over for Nick Faldo on CBS, who has retired.

Smylie Kaufman (NBC/Golf Channel)

With the departure of Roger Maltbie from NBC telecasts, Kaufman, a former PGA Tour player, is set to take on on-course reporting duties. From what little I’ve seen of him on The Golf Channel he’s fairly witty and composed and seems in tune with today’s players. Kaufman, who is buddies with Rickie Fowler, Justin Thomas and Jordan Spieth, was once a can’t miss talent that unpredictably lost his game and flamed out. He has certainly seen the ups and downs of the PGA Tour so hopefully he’ll bring some new, fresh insight to the broadcasts.

Kevin Kisner (NBC)

A notorious trash talker when playing with his buddies in his home state of South Carolina, Kisner, a 4-time winner on the PGA Tour, recently entered the NBC Sports broadcast booth for a couple of events. With his insights as a current player and smooth, Southern sardonic wit, “Kiz” has been well received. He seems at ease and unintimidated by the microphone. Kiz is only gonna get better, too, and many believe, including me, that he has a bright future in the golf announcing biz.

Colt Knost (CBS)

Former pro golfer and 2007 U.S. Amateur champion, Knost is knowledgeable, articulate and opinionated. As a rookie on-course reporter for CBS he’s more into reporting than opinions at this point ,but I see him eventually sharing more of this thoughts ala Dottie Pepper as he gains stable footing in his new role. His performance on the “Featured Group” stream for 2022 Masters was, well, masterful. Knost was brimming with exceptional insight, stories and anecdotes and worked seamlessly with Shane Bacon and Bill Kratzert. I predict big things for him going forward.

Gary Koch (Formerly With NBC)

The analyst who coined the phrase, “Better than Most” tends to agree with the booth guys too much rather than expressing his own opinion. That said, you can’t deny Koch’s knowledge of the game as he has was a star junior and college player, middle-of-the-pack guy on the PGA Tour and a Champions Tour player.

Christina Kim (PGA Tour Live)

Kim has lots of potential as an analyst and commentator, but, at present, her presentation is a bit spotty. She tends to talk too much and her overuse of superlatives like “amazing”, “fabulous” and “incredible” are annoying but make for a good drinking game when you count them up.

Bill Kratzert (Golf Channel)

A former PGA Tour player in the 1970s with four wins, Kratzert is one of these long-time golf analysts that hasn’t worn out his welcome. He sticks to the facts and doesn’t go overboard with his own opinion. He’s knowledgeable about all phases of the game and has that Verne Lundquist type of likable personality. Kratzert does a superb job with Shane Bacon and Colt Knost on “Featured Group” Masters broadcasts.

Justin Leonard (Golf Channel)

Always looking like he just stepped out of a Ralph Lauren Polo advertisement, Leonard is insightful, informative, professional and brings lots of credibility with his successful career on the PGA Tour. Don’t expect a lot of funny one-liners, Leonard’s on-air game is all about letting you know what the players think inside the ropes.

Rich Lerner (Golf Channel)

A smooth talker, adept at reading a teleprompter and well versed in statistics, Lerner is a thorough professional who rarely makes a mistake. He’s very comfortable in front of the camera and never seems to get rattled.

Davis Love III (Formerly with CBS)

He’s better than Melatonin or Sominex. If I need a good snooze on the couch while watching golf, the soft, melodic tones of Love III’s voice sends me quickly to snoozeville. I have always admired Love as a player and Ryder Cup Captain, but he doesn’t bring much dynamism to the broadcast. Like most Pro golfers turned analysts, he noticeably tiptoes around any criticism of his brethren. (DLIII didn’t last long at CBS and announced he was returning to competitive golf). A good move on his part.

Verne Lundquist

While the 80-year old Lundquist has lost a little off his fastball, I still enjoy his commentary and calls on the par 3 No. 16 at the Masters. His “Yes, sir” call at the 1986 Masters and “In your life have you seen anything like that?” in 2005 when Tiger made his miracle chip shot are part of Masters lore. He’ll be difficult to replace when he eventually steps down from the tower.

Jim “Bones” Mackay (Formerly With NBC)

The former caddie to Phil Mickelson sounds exactly like, well, a caddie. I like his act and really enjoy his information about reading greens and how to approach certain putts. He seems to improve with each tournament. (Mackay recently left his course reporter gig to caddie for Justin Thomas).

Hunter Mahan (NBC)

While he’s not on main broadcasts, Mahan should be. He’s articulate and a great storyteller about his life on the PGA Tour. His performance as an analyst at Ryder Cup 2021 “Featured Groups” stream for NBC/Golf Channel was superb. The three-time Ryder Cupper is easy-to-listen to and has a great sense of humor when the moment calls for it. I predict bigger and better things for him in the golf broadcast universe.

Roger Maltbie (Formerly With NBC)

A former PGA Tour player, ol’ “Rodge” is a reliable, venerable, on-the-course reporter who has that comfortable, drinking buddy kind of demeanor that is never irritating. You can easily imagine having a single malt or a pint with Maltbie and listening to his colorful golf stories.

Paul McGinley (Golf Channel)

Wow, who knew he was such a flame thrower. McGinley provides entertaining “in-your-face” challenges to Brandel Chamblee and the Irishman isn’t afraid to share his honest opinion on just about any topic in golf. He’s really a breath of fresh air and has a bit of the Johnny Miller flair for offering constructive criticism in an honest and direct manner. McGinley won four events on the European Tour, sunk the winning putt for Europe in the 2002 Ryder Cup and was the winning captain for Europe in the 2014 Ryder Cup,

Jim Nantz (CBS)

Hello friends, nobody in the business does it like Jim Nantz. While you can criticize him for being too mushy or overdramatic when talking about the Masters and Augusta National, Nantz is always well prepared and unruffled on the air. He makes few mistakes and doesn’t impose his personality on the viewer. It’s an art to be on the air for so long and not annoy the heck out of people and to sit calmly and sometimes listen to Nick Faldo drone on endlessly.

Frank Nobilo (CBS)

With his great New Zealand accent and an ability to talk on every aspect of life on the PGA Tour, Nobilo is one of the best golf analysts on television. He’s not afraid to criticize, but always does it fairly with facts to back up his assertions.

Andy North (ESPN)

Knowledgeable, professional and comfortable in front of the camera, North, a two-time U.S. Open Champion, seems like a nice guy you’d go to for golf advice. North doesn’t say anything even close to controversial so most television viewers probably couldn’t pick him out of a line-up of popular analysts. He probably gets more recognition from his spokesperson duties for the Square Strike Wedge infomercials, which ran incessantly on golf programming a couple of years ago.

Arron Oberholser (NBC/Golf Channel)

A tower analyst and on-course reporter, Oberholser, a former PGA Tour golfer, may not have a big name but he has big-time talent. Vastly underrated and overlooked, Oberholser provides concise, no-nonsense analysis on the best strategies to play holes and the thinking process of golfers he’s covering. His playing career was cut short by injuries, but he’s performing well in this second career as a broadcaster.

Dottie Pepper (CBS)

A two-time major winner, Pepper is excellent at describing the physical and mental intricacies of playing professional golf at the highest level. She’s also not afraid to ruffle a few feathers once in a while. If you want a strong opinion, she delivers. Although she’s mellowed since her recent return to televised golf last year, who can forget her legendary line calling the 2007 Solheim Cup American team “choking freaking dogs.”

Morgan Pressel (NBC/Golf Channel)

While continuing to compete on the LPGA Tour, Pressel, a major champion (2007 ANA Inspiration), recently joined NBC/Golf Channel as an analyst and on-course reporter for LPGA and PGA Tour events. For someone with limited experience broadcasting, Pressel is excellent. She relates well to today’s players and her analysis is concise, honest and well delivered. If you’re looking for the next Dottie Pepper or Judy Rankin, I believe its Pressel, especially when she devotes full-time to her broadcasting career.

Judy Rankin (Golf Channel – Recently Retired)

She exudes class and knows both the men’s and women’s game. In fact, she was the first woman to work full-time on broadcasts of men’s events. Rankin knows the LPGA better than anybody (after all, she served as the Tour president in 1976-77). Articulate and knowledgeable, Rankin never gets flustered and always puts the viewer in a good mood.

Tom Rinaldi (Fox)

I used to like Rinaldi’s soft approach and heart-warming human interest pieces and post game interviews. I can’t take it anymore, though. Everything he does now has a certain sameness and predictability. He asks the same old and tired three questions: “How do you feel?”, “What were you thinking?” and “Why did you cry?”

Jimmy Roberts (Golf Channel)

Roberts sometimes gets a little over-sappy like Tom Rinaldi, but I’ll take Roberts for my heart tugging golf essays and interviews. Apparently I’m not the only one that likes Roberts because he’s racked up 13 Emmy Awards. He’s a superb storyteller and generally stays away from the oh so predictable “how does it feel?” question.

Mark Rolfing (NBC)

A steady voice of reason on the airwaves for more than two decades, Rolfing oozes professionalism and is very underrated. He’s honest and fair in his critiques of player strategy and performance. No puff stuff with Rolfing just great straightforward analysis.

Charlie Rymer (Formerly Golf Channel)

He sounds a bit like Gomer Pyle’s long lost cousin with his syrupy southern accent, but Rymer, a former star at Georgia Tech and a PGA Tour player, has some interesting takes and opinions. He doesn’t like to criticize other players much, but that doesn’t stop him from providing spot on analysis with a cornpone flair.

Steve Sands (Golf Channel)

This gravelly voice broadcast veteran is always reliable with accurate information on the players and tournaments. He’s well connected and respected by the players and PGA Tour officials and presents interesting behind-the-scenes information that enhances the telecast.

Marty Smith (ESPN)

With his syrupy southern twang and folksy demeanor, Smith sounds and looks like the ideal analyst for SEC football and NASCAR. He does an admirable job at both sports for ESPN. Surprisingly, he does an excellent job of post round interviews with golfers, many who are frustrated and tired. Polite and friendly, Smith’s questions are concise and the players seem comfortable talking about the ups and downs of their day.

Curtis Strange (ESPN)

Remember, this is the guy who sanctimoniously told a young, confident Tiger Woods in 1996 that “You’ll learn” when referring to Woods’ goal to win every tournament. Strange still appears a bit uncomfortable talking about Tiger after all these years. Curtis also seems like the grouchy old guy at the clubhouse grill who might offer up this “kick-in-the-balls” retort to Joe Golfer: “Hey, I won two U.S. Opens and you can’t even break 90, get out of my face with your opinion.”

Wright Thompson (ESPN)

A senior writer for ESPN and golf essayist, Thompson, author of the best selling book “Pappyland: A Story of Family, Fine Bourbon and The Things that Last” is skilled at clearly articulating the struggles, hopes and disappointments of golfers without being sappy or overly dramatic. His video essays on the Masters are beautifully written and strike the right balance between describing the majesty of the tournament and the realities of glorious success and devastating defeat.

Mike Tirico (NBC)

Possessing some great pipes for broadcasting, Tirico has the type of voice I never get tired of hearing. He brings immense professionalism to the booth regardless of what sport he’s broadcasting. You can tell he loves golf and he hardly ever makes a mistake.

Scott Van Pelt (ESPN)

SVP is one of the best things going for ESPN. He’s got the smooth talking professionalism of Jim Nantz and spins some great stories along the way as well as solid analysis mixed in with some good humor. His relationship with Tiger Woods dates back to SVP’s days at The Golf Channel, where he got his start in the broadcasting biz. SVP has lots of credibility when it comes to covering El Tigre.

Bubba Watson (LIV Golf)

Since Watson was injured when he joined LIV Golf for some serious loot, he had to earn his keep in some manner. They decided to use him as some sort of “man of the people” analyst with takes – some of them ridiculous – about how great LIV is and how excited he is to be on the new Tour, blah, blah, blah… Bubba Watson is all about Bubba Watson and it comes through in his delivery, which I find exceptionally boring.

Michelle Wie West (Golf Channel)

With her teenage heroics and long-time play on the LPGA Tour, her credibility is unquestioned. Wie West’s pleasant personality is a strong asset, but in these early stages of her broadcasting career she speaks in way too many generalities. Hopefully that will change as she learns how to be a professional broadcaster and not just an ultra-successful athlete that happened to score a role in front of the camera.

John Wood (NBC/Golf Channel)

“Woody” as his broadcasting sidekicks like to call him is a former PGA Tour caddie who is extremely knowledgeable and witty. He does a great job of explaining why players make certain decisions on the course as well as imparting inside information the viewer might not know. In his illustrious looper career, Wood was on the bag for Matt Kuchar, Hunter Mahan, Mark Calcavecchia and others. He also caddied in Ryder Cups, Presidents Cups and The Olympics.

Subscribe to my mailing list